Click here to show or hide the menubar.

Home >  Archive >  2012 >  July >  27

Previous / Next

Do I care what Apple does with RSS?
By Dave Winer on Friday, July 27, 2012 at 12:54 PM.
A fair number of people are asking me what I think about Apple and RSS, so I might as well put the answer on my blog. permalink
They just made a change, taking it out of the UI of Safari. I'm okay with this because I hated what they were doing with it. Hopefully they will let me look at the feed when I click a link to it, instead of showing me a mangled version. permalink
None of the browser guys asked me what I thought they should do with RSS. Actually Microsoft did, but when I expressed an opinion they looked at me in an odd way as if to say "We didn't know you could talk." They ignored everything I asked them to do. It didn't turn out that they took over the world as they were sure they would. Almost everything they did was predicated on the assumption that they would.  permalink
A picture named loverss.jpegI don't think the browser guys ever understood RSS or liked it very much. Their idea was to try to sweep it away, or make it look like a website, but they couldn't make up their minds, and their implementations were all over the map. I'd say they hurt the cause by adding all that confusion. So when Apple pulls back, I'm okay with that. permalink
If I had to guess their motives, I'd say it probably goes something like this. Not too many people are using this feature, and it confuses everyone, so let's take it out. permalink
It might be more nefarious, but honestly, I only care a little, and I don't have the bandwidth to pay much attention to the things I don't care about a lot. permalink
What I recommend is to do this -- put an XML icon on your website. Point it to your feed. Don't say "Click here to subscribe" because that isn't what happens. If you feel you have to say anything, just say "this is my feed."  permalink
Try to have the feed you link to correspond to the HTML content they're looking at. That's a good consistency to try to establish. permalink
Beyond that, there isn't much more any of us can do at this point. It's a fairly tangled mess. Try to see it as good news that the browser guys are getting out of this space, that means some of the tangled mess is going away.  permalink
RSS feed for Scripting News
This site contributes to the community river.

© Copyright 1997-2012 Dave Winer. Last update: Friday, July 27, 2012 at 1:03 PM Eastern. Last build: 7/31/2012; 3:41:07 PM. "It's even worse than it appears."

RSS feed for Scripting News

Previous / Next