Click here to show or hide the menubar.

Home >  Archive >  2010 >  November >  30

Previous / Next

I'd love to buy a podcast player
By Dave Winer on Tuesday, November 30, 2010 at 9:59 AM.

A picture named santa.gifI find the iPod software too cumbersome for listening to podcasts. I want something lighter with features that make sense for 1-hour-long programs, as opposed to 4-minute-long songs.  permalink

Nowadays the functionality I want could be done in software, either for Android or the iPhone. I carry both all the time. But I'd still prefer to carry a medium-size device just for playing podcasts.  permalink

In case someone is interested in making this product, here's how it would work. permalink

1. The device plugs in through the USB port as a hard drive. I copy the MP3s into a folder which can then be played through the UI of the device. If this is iPhone software, I create a playlist in iTunes that contains all my podcasts. permalink

2. At any time there are a bunch of programs in the podcast queue. permalink

3. I can hit the pause button on a podcast, and it remembers the position. I can then skip to the next one, or choose the next one from a list.  permalink

4. When I come back around to the one I just paused the playback picks up where I left off. permalink

5. When I make it to the end of a show, it goes in the trash. I can empty the trash later when I'm putting more programs on the device, or leave it there in case I want to listen to it again (I don't think I've actually done this even once, in six years of podcast listening). permalink

6. If it's a standalone device, I don't want to pay more than $30. Apple's players are way too expensive, so are Sony's. permalink

A picture named walkman1980s.jpgIdeally I'd like this to be a device, not an app, because even though both platforms claim to do multi-tasking, they behave unpredictably. I shot a movie the other day while listening to a podcast, and the podcast stopped, and when I resumed I had to start over from the beginning. On the original iPod I knew how to fast-forward to a new location, but they changed the UI, and when I'm out and about there's nothing dumber than having to stop on the side of the street for five minutes to get the software to behave itself. I had one moment where the iPod told me it had to rebuild something and I should be patient. I was standing in the middle of Houston Street with traffic all around me, and the programmers back in Cupertino programming want me to be patient. Hello.  permalink

I used a Sony Walkman for a while and loved it. It does almost all of the items on my list, but not the crucial one -- #4 -- picking up where I left off on multiple podcasts. This is a big feature. I can read three books at the same time, there's nothing so weird about wanting to "read" three podcasts simultaneously. The Kindle does this admirably. Hey maybe Amazon should make an audio book reader? Thinking out loud. permalink

BTW, the Walkman that I love crapped out on me. It's stuck in a loop rebuilding its library.  permalink

I know people are going to tell me about products that kind of do some of what I want, or do something completely different. I think there's a $30 sweet spot out there that everyone is missing. Music and podcasts are very different forms and require different approaches. permalink

RSS feed for Scripting News
This site contributes to the community river.

© Copyright 1997-2012 Dave Winer. Last update: Tuesday, November 30, 2010 at 10:53 AM Eastern. Last build: 8/26/2012; 6:01:45 PM. "It's even worse than it appears."

RSS feed for Scripting News

Previous / Next